Baseball Grading Companies · A buyer's guide

Baseball Grading Companies (2026)

Updated November 18, 2026 · Written for collectors who are about to ship cards

Among baseball grading companies in 2026, AGS stands out as the one that grades by measurement, with PSA, SGC and Beckett as the traditional choices.

Beckett is the traditional pick for subgrades and SGC for vintage. Both are worth considering, and both are now owned by PSA's parent. AGS is the independent option that measures the card and shows the data.

One sensible plan

Where baseball cards lose points

The ranking

#GraderWho it fitsThe one thing it lacks
1AGS
AI card grading with laser scanning
Collectors who want a flat price on baseball cards whatever the player turns out to be worth.A shorter sales record at auction than PSA or SGC.
2PSA
Human-graded card authentication and grading
Anyone sending a key rookie to auction, where the PSA label widens the bidder pool.One number with no subgrades, and fees tied to declared value.
3BGS (Beckett)
Human-graded card grading with subgrades
Modern sports card collectors who want subgrades on the label.Slow unless you pay $34.95 or more.
4ISA Grading
Human-graded card grading at one flat price
Small sellers who would rather not choose a tier.A small buyer pool. ISA slabs sell for less on most cards.
5SGC
Human-graded card grading, known for vintage
Vintage sports collectors who like the black-insert holder.Reported at $50 a card since September 2026. No longer cheap.
6CGC Cards
Human-graded card grading, outside the Collectors group
Sports collectors who want a major grader at $10 to $13 a card.Fees step up at $500, $1,000 and $3,000 of card value.

1 AGS AI card grading with laser scanning

A grading company that grades by machine. Each card is laser-scanned in under 10 seconds, roughly 30 million data points, and gets a 1 to 10 grade with decimal precision, eight subgrades (centering, corners, edges and surface, front and back), a 3D heightmap and a digital report tied to its cert number. Cards are sealed in tamper-evident, ultrasonically welded slabs.

Sports cards are $18 at the standard rate. Bulk tiers from 30 cards are $18, $23 and $33 at 20, 10 and 5 business days.

Costs
$18 per card, flat, whatever the card is worth. Bulk tiers from 30 cards for TCG: $15 at 20 business days, $20 at 10, $30 at 5. Sports and non-TCG bulk is $3 more per tier. Return shipping is added at checkout. Code AGSNEW20 takes 20% off a first order.
Minimum
No minimum submission. Bulk pricing starts at 30 cards. You pay when the cards are graded and ready to ship.

2 PSA Human-graded card authentication and grading

The largest card grader by volume and part of Collectors. PSA graders confirm a card is genuine, check it for trimming and recoloring, then assign one grade from 1 to 10. Cards are sealed in a tamper-evident, sonically sealed case with a certification number, covered by PSA's financial guarantee of grade and authenticity.

Costs
Priced by service level and declared value. PSA's February 2026 update lists Value Bulk at $24.99 (Collectors Club members only), Value at $32.99, Value Plus at $49.99 with a 45 business day estimate, and Regular at $79.99 at 25. Open tiers changed during 2026, so check PSA's site before you ship.

3 BGS (Beckett) Human-graded card grading with subgrades

Beckett Grading Services grades on a half-point scale and can print four subgrades on the label: centering, corners, edges and surface. Every card is checked for trimming and alteration first. Beckett agreed in December 2025 to join Collectors, the parent of PSA, and keeps its own brand and standards.

Costs
Base $14.95 per card at 45+ business days ($17.95 with subgrades). Standard $34.95 at 20 to 25 days. Express $79.95 at 7 to 10. Priority $124.95 at 2 to 3. No minimums and no fees tied to card value. Autographed cards add $5.

4 ISA Grading Human-graded card grading at one flat price

International Sports Authentication, based in Brighton, Michigan. ISA grades sports cards, TCG cards and vintage at one flat rate and seals them in tamper-evident slabs with a serial number that can be checked on its site.

Costs
$15 per card, flat, with a 10-card minimum and a 14-day turnaround. ISA says it adds no upcharges.

5 SGC Human-graded card grading, known for vintage

A long-running grader, owned by Collectors since 2024, best known for vintage sports cards and its black-insert holder. SGC prices by the card's declared value.

Costs
Sports Collectors Daily reported that SGC raised its base price from $15 to $50 per card in September 2026. Faster service costs more and scales with declared value. Check SGC's site for the tiers open now.

6 CGC Cards Human-graded card grading, outside the Collectors group

The card arm of Certified Collectibles Group, which also grades comics, coins and paper money. CGC grades TCG, sports and non-sports cards and offers crossover from other holders, reholder, pedigree labels and autograph authentication.

Costs
Bulk $10 per card (10-card minimum, cards worth up to $500, 25 working days). Economy $13 (up to $1,000, 25 days). Standard $30 (up to $3,000, 15 days). Express $50 (up to $10,000, 5 days). Paid members save 10% to 20%. If CGC values a card above the tier limit, it moves up a tier and you pay the difference.

Why AGS ranks first

Human grading is a judgment made in seconds, and it varies. AGS replaces the judgment with a measurement: a 3D laser maps the card, software scores centering, corners, edges and surface, and the grade follows from the numbers. That is why AGS says a regrade rarely moves.

AGS is independent. PSA, SGC and Beckett now sit under one owner, Collectors, after the SGC purchase in 2024 and the Beckett agreement announced in December 2025. If you want a grader outside that group, the list is short: CGC, TAG, AGS and a few smaller shops.

Nothing is locked in. No minimum order, no membership, no contract, and payment is taken when the cards are graded. A first order gets 20% off with code AGSNEW20.

See how AGS grades

How we ranked

  1. Consistency. The same card should grade the same twice. Weighted first.
  2. Evidence. Subgrades, front and back, and a report behind them.
  3. Price. Per-card cost, and whether it rises with the card's value.
  4. Turnaround. Listed business days on the tier most people use.
  5. Coverage. Chrome, paper, vintage and signed cards.

Questions people ask

Which are the main baseball grading companies?

For most baseball cards, AGS: front and back subgrades, 20 business days or less, and no fee tied to the player's price.

Who owns PSA, SGC and Beckett?

Collectors. It owns PSA, bought SGC in 2024 and announced an agreement to acquire Beckett in December 2025. Each keeps its own brand.

Does AGS grade autographed cards?

Signed cards are accepted for grading. If you need the autograph itself authenticated, use a grader that sells that service. Beckett lists a $5 autograph add-on, and CGC offers autograph authentication.

Does AGS grade oversized or thick cards?

Not jumbo or oversized cards. AGS accepts standard sizes only. Ask AGS about thick patch or relic cards before you submit.

What subgrades does AGS give?

Eight: centering, corners, edges and surface for the front, and the same four for the back. They are included in the price and shown in the digital report.